When Kindness Becomes the Only Virtue
What Jesus and his apostles teach about mercy,
accountability, and the stranger at our border
A Christian can bring a meal to a family facing
deportation and still believe the government should enforce immigration law.
That strikes some people as a contradiction.
If enforcement brings hardship to a peaceable family, how
can a kind person support it? The question deserves an answer, especially if it
is our neighbor who may be sent away. It also deserves a second question. Where
did Jesus teach that the kindest thing in the moment is always the right thing
to do?
The kindness Jesus taught
“Love
is patient, love is kind,” Paul writes. Two verses later, he says love
“rejoices with the truth” (New International Version, 1978/2011, 1 Corinthians
13:4–6). We often remember the first line when somebody needs comfort. We need
the second when somebody needs to hear what we would rather leave unsaid. In
Romans, Paul says that God’s kindness is meant to lead us to repentance.
Apparently, God can be kind to us while asking us to change (Romans 2:4).
Consider
the rich man who asked Jesus how to inherit eternal life. Mark tells us that
Jesus looked at him and loved him. Then Jesus told him to sell what he owned,
give to the poor, and follow him. The man went away sorrowful (Mark 10:17–22).
Mark could hardly have made the point more plainly. Jesus loved the man before
he spoke, and the man’s sorrow did not make the counsel any less loving. A
church that treats every painful truth as an act of unkindness would have had
to ask Jesus to call the man back and take back his words.
Jesus
rebuked religious leaders who tithed garden herbs while neglecting “justice,
mercy and faithfulness.” He told them to attend to the weightier matters while
also attending to the others (Matthew 23:23). The warning cuts both ways. We
can use rules to excuse our indifference to suffering. We can also invoke
compassion to excuse ourselves from asking what justice requires. Thomas
Aquinas, writing about God’s justice and mercy, argued that mercy can fulfill
justice by giving more than is owed (Aquinas, ca. 1265–1274/1920, I, q. 21,
art. 3, reply to obj. 2). That helps explain why mercy makes sense only when
we have first asked what is owed.
When
kindness becomes the test of every Christian teaching, repentance starts to
sound like judgmentalism, correction like cruelty, and forgiveness like a
declaration that nothing wrong happened. Paul gives the church a different
instruction. If someone is caught in sin, restore that person gently, and watch
yourself in the process (Galatians 6:1). It takes humility to correct someone
gently. It also takes enough love to risk a conversation that may cost you
their approval.
What Christians owe the stranger
Scripture
gives Christians ample reason to care for immigrants. Israel was commanded to
love the foreigner residing among them and to remember what it was like to be
foreigners in Egypt (Leviticus 19:33–34). In the parable of the Good Samaritan,
the man who sees a wounded stranger takes responsibility for the help he can
give (Luke 10:25–37). If a family in my town is hungry, I do not need to know their
immigration status before bringing groceries. The command to love my neighbor
gives me plenty to do.
Paul
also tells Christians to respect governing authorities, describing their
office as a service for the good (Romans 13:1–7). The apostles themselves
refused an order that would have required them to disobey God (Acts 5:27–29).
Taken together, those passages give civil authority a real place and a moral
limit. Augustine likewise saw earthly peace and the laws that sustain it as
goods Christians share with their neighbors, while recognizing that fidelity to
God can put limits on what Christians may comply with (City of God,
XIX.17).
I
take these teachings to give a government moral grounds to regulate admission
and enforce fair rules. They also give Christians grounds to question an unjust
rule or protest a cruel enforcement practice. Scripture leaves us to exercise
judgment about admissions, penalties, and exceptions. If we think a consequence
is disproportionate, we should explain what makes it so. If a particular
family’s circumstances call for mercy, we can make that case honestly and seek
whatever discretion the law allows. An official who owes a fair hearing to the
person facing removal also owes a fair process to those who waited and met the
conditions of admission. Both are neighbors, even if only one is standing in
front of us.
What a nation can lose
History
gives us reasons to ask what happens when a government loses control over the
scale or terms of settlement. In 406, the Vandals and their allies crossed the
Rhine into Roman territory. They eventually moved through Spain into Roman
North Africa and took Carthage in 439. Rome lost control of a wealthy province,
and Carthage became the capital of a rival kingdom. The Vandals brought
military power with them, and military power was decisive in the outcome
(Conant, 2012).
The
history of Texas raises a question closer to home. Mexico initially permitted
settlers from the United States to establish colonies in Texas. Concerned by
the growth of immigration and developments in the province, Mexico moved to
restrict immigration from the United States in 1830. Settler communities had
already put down roots and acquired political weight. The conflict that
followed had several causes, including disputes over slavery and Mexican
centralization, and independence ultimately came through war. Still, the
challenge to Mexico’s authority took shape through years of settlement before
the revolution. Americans ought to find it easy to understand why a country
would care about that possibility. In this case, we supplied the settlers
(Henson, n.d.; U.S. House of Representatives, n.d.).
The
recent U.S. immigration surge illustrates effects well short of any contest
over sovereignty. The Congressional Budget Office estimated that in 2023 the
surge brought state and local governments $10.1 billion in additional direct
revenue and $19.3 billion in additional direct spending, much of it for
schools, shelter, and border security. In a separate projection, it estimated
that the same surge would lower federal deficits over a decade. Both estimates
can be true. The community that has to make room in its classrooms this fall
may face costs even as the country as a whole gains workers and federal revenue
(Congressional Budget Office, 2024, 2025).
Invasion
Without an Army
Can
something like an invasion take place without an army crossing the border? If
what we mean is an effort to displace the authority of a country over part of
its territory or over the people who live there, armed force is one means of
pursuing it. An organized movement could use elections and local offices to
advance a rival claim to authority. Settlement on a large scale can give such a
movement political weight where enough people reject the laws and civic
obligations that hold a community together. Winning a local election gives a
movement influence over local decisions.
In the
United States, state and federal law and constitutional rights still bind local
officials (U.S. Const. amend. I, art. VI, cl. 2). Numbers alone tell us little
about what a movement intends to do with the power it gains. We would need to
look at what people actually organize to do and which rights they would deny
their neighbors. A man can speak a different language at home, worship
differently from me, and honor the law we both live under. A movement that
seeks to punish a neighbor for changing religions is making a claim to power
that deserves to be opposed, however peacefully it campaigns.
Jesus’
teaching gives me reason to care about the person at my door and the public
peace we share. I can bring the groceries, insist that the family be treated
fairly, and ask whether their circumstances call for mercy. I can also expect
the government to enforce just laws and give reasons when it makes exceptions.
If I want my view of immigration to be Christian, I have to let Jesus tell me
what love requires even when his answer makes my politics less comfortable.
References
Aquinas, T.
(1920). Summa theologica (Fathers of the English Dominican Province,
Trans., 2nd rev. ed.), Part I, Question 21. New Advent. (Original work written
ca. 1265–1274). https://www.newadvent.org/summa/1021.htm
Augustine of
Hippo. (1887). The city of God, Book XIX (M. Dods, Trans.). In P. Schaff
(Ed.), Nicene and post-Nicene fathers (First Series, Vol. 2). Christian
Literature Publishing Co. (Original work published ca. 426). https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/120119.htm
Conant, J.
(2012). Staying Roman: Conquest and identity in Africa and the
Mediterranean, 439–700. Cambridge University Press. https://assets.cambridge.org/97805211/96970/excerpt/9780521196970_excerpt.pdf
Congressional
Budget Office. (2024, July). Effects of the immigration surge on the federal
budget and the economy. https://www.cbo.gov/publication/60569
Congressional
Budget Office. (2025, June 5). Effects of the surge in immigration on state
and local budgets in 2023. https://www.cbo.gov/publication/61256
Henson, M.
S. (n.d.). Anglo-American colonization. Handbook of Texas Online. Texas
State Historical Association. https://www.tshaonline.org/handbook/entries/anglo-american-colonization
Holy
Bible, New International Version. (2011). Biblica. (Original work published
1978). https://www.biblegateway.com/versions/New-International-Version-NIV-Bible/
U.S. House
of Representatives. (n.d.). Era of U.S. continental expansion. History,
Art & Archives. https://history.house.gov/Exhibitions-and-Publications/HAIC/Historical-Essays/Continental-Expansion/Era-of-U-S--Continental-Expansion/
#MyGodAndGovernment
#ChristianEthics #LoveYourNeighbor #JusticeAndMercy #ImmigrationPolicy
Follow Tom on Twitter: @ThomasKSheppard
Tom Sheppard is a business consultant and coach to small business owners and individuals. He is a recognized author with dozens of titles in business and fiction to his credit. One of his endeavors is to help those who want to see their own book in print. He does this through his trademarked Book Whispering Process (TM).
The author is not an official spokesperson for any organization or person mentioned herein.
(c) Copyright 2020 A+ Results LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Your comments are welcome... Please observe some ground rules. No profanity, vulgarity, or personal attacks. Profanity, vulgarity and personal attacks not only betray a lack of vocabulary and imagination, they also are the hallmarks of bigotry, and bigotry is the hallmark of someone who is fundamentally insecure in their views. Facts are always welcome.
If you believe Government is NOT the answer to all our problems, you will want to read
Godvernment: Government as God
Godvernment: Government as God

No comments:
Post a Comment
Agree or disagree, I welcome comments. Incivility, vulgarity, and profanity are not tolerated. At best, they will be edited out. At worst, your comment will end up in the trash can.