Was Jesus Divisive? And When Did Divisiveness Become a Sin?
We condemn political leaders for dividing people. But what if the division is between right and wrong?
One of the most common accusations leveled against politicians today is that they are divisive.
The accusation is delivered as though it settles the matter. A politician is divisive, therefore the politician is bad. A leader brings people together, therefore the leader is good.
But is that a sound moral judgment?
I suggest it is not.
In fact, if divisiveness is inherently immoral, we are confronted with a rather uncomfortable problem: Jesus Christ was divisive, and He openly acknowledged it.
That observation should give Christians pause. It should also give thoughtful non-Christians reason to reconsider whether unity and division are appropriate measures of moral leadership.
The real question is not whether someone divides people. It is whether the division serves truth and righteousness or falsehood and wickedness.
And that distinction has profound implications for how we judge our political leaders, our government, and ourselves.
The Prince of Peace Who Brought Division
Jesus Christ is commonly called the Prince of Peace, a title derived from Isaiah 9:6.
He taught His followers to love their neighbors, forgive their enemies, turn the other cheek, and become peacemakers.
Yet He also made this remarkable declaration: “Suppose ye that I am come to give peace on earth? I tell you, Nay; but rather division.” Luke 12:51
In Matthew’s account, His language was even more provocative: “Think not that I am come to send peace on earth: I came not to send peace, but a sword.” Matthew 10:34
In context, the sword represents the conflict His teachings would produce, even within families. It is not a general authorization to employ violence against those who disagree.
Nevertheless, His meaning is unmistakable. Christ understood that His teachings would divide people.
Nor was this merely a prediction about how others might react to Him.
He deliberately confronted the religious and political assumptions of His day. He publicly rebuked religious authorities. He challenged established interpretations of religious law. He exposed hypocrisy among people who enjoyed considerable public respect.
He even drove merchants and money changers from the temple.
By almost any contemporary political standard, Jesus could have been described as a disruptive and divisive figure.
Yet Christians believe Him to have been perfectly righteous.
How do we reconcile these facts?
Perhaps the problem is not with Christ’s conduct, but with our understanding of divisiveness.
Unity Is Not Always Good
We generally regard unity as a virtue, and with good reason.
Families, communities, churches, businesses, and nations accomplish much more when people cooperate toward common objectives.
But unity has no inherent moral value independent of the purpose for which people unite.
A criminal conspiracy may exhibit remarkable unity. Its members may demonstrate loyalty, cooperation, discipline, and a shared commitment to their objectives.
Their unity does not make their objectives righteous.
The Bible provides a particularly interesting example in the account of the Tower of Babel.
According to Genesis 11, the people shared a common language and united in an ambitious undertaking. They sought to build a city and tower, make a name for themselves, and prevent their dispersion.
God disrupted their undertaking by confounding their language.
Whatever else we conclude about this account, one point is unmistakable: God did not regard their unity as sufficient reason to approve their enterprise.
Their collective purpose mattered.
The same principle appears in the conspiracy to arrest and kill Jesus. The chief priests and elders acted together. Their agreement did not sanctify their actions.
History provides countless additional examples of people uniting behind destructive causes.
Unity in the pursuit of evil is not a virtue. Division in opposition to evil is not a vice.
This is a distinction we seem to have forgotten.
When Division Becomes a Moral Obligation
Consider a society in which slavery is legal, widely accepted, and economically important.
Those who challenge the institution necessarily threaten the prevailing social order.
They create controversy. They provoke resentment. They divide communities, churches, political parties, and families.
Would we condemn the abolitionists because their opposition to slavery was divisive?
Certainly, their arguments and methods remain subject to moral scrutiny. Not everything done in pursuit of a righteous cause is automatically righteous.
But the fact that their cause produced division is not evidence against it.
Indeed, if preserving unity requires accepting injustice, then preserving unity becomes morally suspect.
The same reasoning applies to religious reformers, whistleblowers, civil rights advocates, and ordinary citizens who refuse to participate in wrongdoing.
Their actions may disrupt established relationships and institutions.
Sometimes they should.
This does not mean every person who claims to be confronting evil is correct. Fanatics, demagogues, and tyrants have also claimed to defend righteousness.
That is precisely why we need a better standard than whether someone creates controversy.
We need to examine the principles being defended, the truthfulness of the claims being made, and the conduct of those making them.
The Difference Between Division and Contention
Here is a distinction I believe is particularly important.
Division is a condition. Contention is a manner of behaving.
People are divided when they disagree about principles, beliefs, objectives, or loyalties.
They become contentious when their disagreements turn into hostility, anger, personal attacks, and efforts to injure or humiliate one another.
The two are not synonymous.
Two people may disagree profoundly about the proper role of government while treating each other with respect.
Conversely, two people who agree politically may exhibit a thoroughly contentious spirit toward everyone outside their political circle.
Christ’s teachings make this distinction especially meaningful.
He instructed His followers to love their enemies and pray for those who persecuted them (Matthew 5:44).
Notice what He did not say.
He did not instruct His followers to abandon their principles to avoid making enemies.
He did not command them to accept falsehood for the sake of harmony.
Nor did He suggest that love requires agreement.
Instead, He demanded something far more difficult: fidelity to truth accompanied by love for those who reject it.
We can oppose what someone believes without hating the person who believes it.
We can condemn an action without denying the dignity of the person responsible.
We can insist upon justice without demanding vengeance.
And we can defend our principles without manufacturing enemies.
That, I suggest, is the difference between principled division and destructive contention.
Five Tests for Righteous Division
If being divisive is not inherently wrong, how should we judge those whose words and actions divide us?
I propose five tests.
1. The Test of Truth
Is the division grounded in truth, or does it depend upon falsehood, distortion, and deception?
A politician who exposes genuine corruption may provoke considerable division. That does not make the exposure wrong.
A politician who invents allegations of corruption to destroy an opponent is doing something fundamentally different.
The resulting division may look similar, but its moral foundation is not.
Truth must be the first consideration.
And truth does not change depending upon which political party benefits from it.
2. The Test of Principle
What principle is being defended?
Is it a principle that applies equally to everyone, or merely a convenient justification for advancing one’s preferred interests?
Consider freedom of speech.
A politician who defends free expression for political allies while seeking to silence opponents is not defending a principle. That politician is defending a privilege.
The same test applies to religious liberty, equal protection under the law, due process, and constitutional limitations upon government.
A genuine principle does not cease to apply when its application becomes inconvenient.
3. The Test of Conduct
Does the person employ methods consistent with the principles being defended?
One cannot credibly defend honesty through deliberate deception.
One cannot defend liberty by arbitrarily denying it to others.
One cannot defend justice through knowingly unjust conduct.
This does not mean that righteous opposition must always be gentle or agreeable.
Jesus sometimes spoke with extraordinary severity.
But severity and malice are not the same thing.
The question is whether the conduct is justified, proportionate, and directed toward correcting wrong rather than merely inflicting injury.
4. The Test of Purpose
What does the person hope to accomplish?
Is division necessary to expose wrongdoing, correct injustice, or defend a fundamental principle?
Or is division being cultivated because angry, frightened people are easier to manipulate?
There is an enormous difference between a leader who accepts division as the price of doing what is right and a leader who profits from keeping people divided.
Political power can be acquired by convincing people that their neighbors are enemies.
It can also be exercised by persuading people to work together without abandoning their convictions.
We should be especially suspicious of leaders who continually require us to hate someone in order to remain loyal to them.
5. The Test of Fruits
Jesus offered a straightforward principle for evaluating those who claim moral or spiritual authority: “Wherefore by their fruits ye shall know them.” Matthew 7:20
What does the person’s conduct actually produce?
Does it advance justice, protect liberty, expose wrongdoing, encourage responsibility, or establish conditions for lasting peace?
Or does it promote deception, dependency, resentment, intimidation, and the concentration of power?
We must be careful here. Good actions sometimes produce painful immediate consequences. Evil actions sometimes produce temporary prosperity or tranquility.
The fruits must therefore be examined over time, with attention to both intended and unintended consequences.
Nevertheless, the test remains essential.
We should judge leaders by more than their promises, popularity, or ability to excite a crowd.
We should examine what their leadership actually accomplishes.
Government Is Not God
This discussion brings me to a central premise of my book, Godvernment.
Government has a legitimate and necessary role in human society.
But government is not God.
It does not create moral truth by legislative enactment. It does not transform wickedness into righteousness through majority vote. Nor does it acquire unlimited moral authority merely because its officers have been elected.
Laws may recognize and protect rights. They may also violate them.
Governments may administer justice. They may also become instruments of injustice.
Political leaders may serve the people. They may also seek to make the people servants of the state.
When we begin treating government as the ultimate source of right and wrong, we have elevated a human institution into a position it was never entitled to occupy.
This is one of the dangers I explore in Godvernment: the tendency to transfer to government the faith, allegiance, and expectations that properly belong to God.
The consequences reach well beyond religious belief.
When political authority becomes our highest moral authority, disagreement with government can begin to look like wickedness. Opposition to a political program can be portrayed as opposition to goodness itself.
Political conformity then becomes a substitute for righteousness.
And unity becomes an instrument for enforcing conformity rather than a consequence of shared commitment to truth.
A government that demands agreement merely because it possesses power has confused authority with righteousness.
Citizens who surrender their moral judgment to political leaders make the same mistake.
The rightful purpose of government is not to replace individual conscience or divine authority, but to exercise its legitimate powers within moral limits.
That proposition should matter to religious believers and nonbelievers alike. Even those who do not accept divine authority have good reason to reject the notion that government is morally infallible.
The Dangerous Appeal of Political Unity
Politicians frequently promise to unite the country.
That sounds admirable.
But before applauding the promise, we should ask a question:
Unite us around what?
Around constitutional government, equal justice, individual liberty, and mutual responsibility?
Or around unquestioning loyalty to a leader, party, or ideology?
Unity is not a destination. It is a relationship among people pursuing some shared purpose.
The moral worth of that unity depends upon the purpose.
A politician who refuses to compromise a fundamental principle may be accused of dividing the nation.
Another politician who abandons that principle in exchange for popular approval may be celebrated as a unifier.
Yet the first may be acting with integrity while the second is acting out of expediency.
Of course, the reverse may also be true. Stubbornness is not automatically integrity, and compromise is not automatically cowardice.
The distinction depends upon what is being defended or surrendered.
Compromise is often appropriate when we disagree about the practical means of accomplishing legitimate objectives.
It becomes dangerous when it requires abandoning the very principles that make those objectives legitimate.
We should not confuse the willingness to negotiate with the willingness to surrender moral judgment.
The Problem With Calling Someone Divisive
When someone tells me a politician is divisive, I increasingly find myself wanting to ask:
What, specifically, is that politician dividing people over?
Is the politician exposing a genuine disagreement about important principles?
Is the politician confronting wrongdoing that others would prefer to ignore?
Is the politician telling uncomfortable truths?
Or is the politician deliberately spreading falsehoods, encouraging hatred, and exploiting fear?
These are very different possibilities.
Merely calling someone divisive tells me almost nothing about whether the person is right or wrong.
It tells me that people disagree, perhaps passionately.
But disagreement is not a moral verdict.
A politician might be divisive because the politician is defending something important.
A politician might be divisive because the politician is behaving disgracefully.
And sometimes both can be true: a leader may defend a worthy principle while employing methods that deserve condemnation.
That last possibility is especially important.
We must resist the temptation to excuse dishonesty, cruelty, or abuses of power merely because the person responsible claims to be defending principles we share.
If our principles are genuine, they must govern our allies as well as our adversaries.
Otherwise, they are not principles at all. They are preferences.
Peace Without Surrender
We return, finally, to Jesus Christ.
How could the Prince of Peace declare that He came to bring division?
I believe the answer is that He understood something we frequently overlook.
There is a difference between peace and the absence of disagreement.
A family may appear peaceful because everyone is afraid to challenge an abusive member.
A business may appear harmonious because employees know that reporting misconduct will end their careers.
A nation may appear united because dissent has been suppressed.
None of these conditions necessarily represents genuine peace.
Peace founded upon fear, deception, or injustice is fragile at best.
Christ offered something different.
His teachings called people to repentance, righteousness, forgiveness, and reconciliation with God.
Those teachings necessarily confronted beliefs and practices that were incompatible with His message.
Division followed.
But division was not the ultimate objective.
Truth, righteousness, and reconciliation were.
This suggests that genuine peace is not achieved by pretending that fundamental disagreements do not exist.
It is achieved by addressing those disagreements honestly, justly, and with proper regard for the humanity of those involved.
Sometimes that requires compromise.
Sometimes it requires forgiveness.
And sometimes it requires the courage to stand alone.
The Question We Should Be Asking
I do not believe we should evaluate our political leaders according to how many people they offend or how many people applaud them.
Nor should we assume that controversy proves courage or that popularity proves wisdom.
We should ask whether they tell the truth, uphold sound principles, respect the rights of others, exercise legitimate authority responsibly, and remain accountable for their conduct.
We should examine whether their actions promote justice or injustice, liberty or oppression, responsibility or dependency.
And we should apply those standards without regard to political party.
If a leader divides people by exposing corruption, defending fundamental rights, or confronting injustice, the division may be justified.
If a leader divides people through deception, hatred, intimidation, or the calculated exploitation of fear, the division deserves condemnation.
The distinction is not always easy to make. It requires evidence, humility, discernment, and a willingness to recognize wrongdoing even among those we support.
But the difficulty of making that judgment does not excuse us from making it.
Jesus Christ was divisive.
That fact alone should be sufficient to demonstrate that divisiveness is not universally evil.
The same Jesus commanded us to love our enemies and blessed the peacemakers.
That fact should prevent us from using righteousness as an excuse for hatred.
The question is not whether a leader divides us. The question is whether the leader is dividing us from evil or dividing us against one another.
Those are not the same thing.
And perhaps the next time someone condemns a political leader for being divisive, we should respond with a simple question:
“Divisive over what?”
About the Author
Tom Sheppard is a business consultant, author, and commentator on the relationship between faith, government, individual liberty, and personal responsibility. He is the author of Godvernment, which examines the consequences of elevating government into the role of ultimate moral authority. Through My God and Government, he explores political and social questions through the lens of enduring moral principles.
Scripture References
All biblical quotations are from the King James Version.
- Genesis 11:1–9. The Tower of Babel.
- Isaiah 9:6. The Prince of Peace.
- Matthew 5:9, 44. Peacemaking and love for enemies.
- Matthew 7:15–20. Knowing people by their fruits.
- Matthew 10:34–36. Christ’s teachings and division.
- Matthew 21:12–13. The cleansing of the temple.
- Matthew 23. Christ’s rebuke of religious hypocrisy.
- Luke 12:51–53. Division resulting from Christ’s ministry.
- John 17:20–23. Christ’s prayer for unity.
Follow Tom on Twitter: @ThomasKSheppard
Tom Sheppard is a business consultant and coach to small business owners and individuals. He is a recognized author with dozens of titles in business and fiction to his credit. One of his endeavors is to help those who want to see their own book in print. He does this through his trademarked Book Whispering Process (TM).
The author is not an official spokesperson for any organization or person mentioned herein.
(c) Copyright 2020 A+ Results LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Your comments are welcome... Please observe some ground rules. No profanity, vulgarity, or personal attacks. Profanity, vulgarity and personal attacks not only betray a lack of vocabulary and imagination, they also are the hallmarks of bigotry, and bigotry is the hallmark of someone who is fundamentally insecure in their views. Facts are always welcome.
If you believe Government is NOT the answer to all our problems, you will want to read
Godvernment: Government as God
Godvernment: Government as God
